If your shingle roof is due for replacement, ask for two prices on the same roof: one for new shingles and one for metal. Asphalt shingles usually cost less up front. The metal price depends in part on whether the panels use exposed fasteners or a standing seam with concealed fasteners. Ask which system the roofer priced before comparing totals.
What changes when you switch from shingles to metal?
Have the estimator show where the proposed panels will end. A house with a low-slope porch or rear addition may need a different roof covering on that section. Ask how the crew will join the two surfaces and whether the written price covers both.
With exposed-fastener metal, the screws and sealing washers are exposed to the weather. Ask what maintenance the manufacturer calls for. For a standing-seam quote, ask which panel profile and finish are included. For a shingle quote, ask for the product name so you can compare the same grade across bids.
How to compare two roof estimates
- Removal and disposal. Check whether each price includes removing the existing roof and hauling it away.
- Roof decking. Ask how much damaged plywood is included and what each additional sheet would cost. The full extent of damage may only become visible during tear-off.
- Flashing and low-slope sections. Look for the work around chimneys, walls and pipe penetrations, along with any separately priced porch or addition.
- Warranty and payment. Read what the manufacturer covers, what the roofer covers and when each payment comes due. If insurance cost affects your choice, ask your carrier to quote the proposed system before signing.
Standing seam and exposed-fastener repair and replacement are on the metal roofing page. This post is the comparison.
For a home in Plant City, Lakeland or elsewhere in True Roofers’ service area, request a roof replacement estimate or call (813) 800-1800. Mention that you want shingle and metal options, and tell us about any attached porch or flat roof.